Sonny Gray kicks off his Red Sox journey with a bold statement that’s sure to ruffle some feathers: he’s thrilled to join a team where hating the Yankees comes naturally. But here’s where it gets controversial—Gray didn’t hold back when reflecting on his time in New York, admitting, ‘I never wanted to go there in the first place.’ Ouch. During a video conference with reporters on Tuesday, Gray openly shared that his move to Boston was partly fueled by the intense rivalry with the Yankees. ‘It’s easy to hate the Yankees, right?’ he said with a grin. ‘I like the challenge.’ And this is the part most people miss—despite his rocky tenure with the Yankees, Gray credits that experience for shaping him into a better player and person.
Gray’s journey with the Yankees began in 2017 when the A’s traded him to New York as the centerpiece of a four-player deal. However, his time there was less than stellar, posting a 4.51 ERA over 41 appearances (34 starts) before being shipped off to the Reds. He was candid about the mismatch, stating the move ‘just didn’t really work for who I am’ and wasn’t ideal for him or his family. Yet, the irony? Gray has since thrived, making two All-Star teams and even finishing as a runner-up for the American League Cy Young Award in 2023 with the Twins.
‘I do appreciate my time [in New York],’ Gray reflected. ‘The last seven years, I’ve become a better baseball player, husband, and person because of that experience.’ But he also admitted that initially, he felt stifled, unable to ‘just go out there and be Sonny.’ Now, as he embarks on his Red Sox career, Gray seems ready to embrace the rivalry with full force—and fans are here for it.
Controversial question for you: Is Gray’s candid criticism of the Yankees justified, or does it cross the line? And does his success post-Yankees prove that sometimes, a change of scenery is all a player needs? Let us know in the comments!
Looking for the perfect holiday gift for the Red Sox fan in your life? Check out the official MLB Shop for exclusive deals: Red Sox Holiday Gifts.
For a deeper dive into what Gray’s trade means for Boston, explore these FAQs: Questions Facing the Red Sox After Trading for Sonny Gray.*
